Tech Blog

Android vs iPhone vs Pre vs Blackberry: It's About the Software, Stupid.

by Blogger on ‎06-01-2009 06:20 AM - last edited on ‎04-27-2012 05:40 PM by Moderator

To turn a phrase from Bill Clinton, the impending armageddon of new phone platforms arriving on Canadian shores this month will be settled not on the hardware side, but on the software side.

 

20090601android.gif

 

Tomorrow Google launches it's Android platform in Canada on the Rogers network with the HTC Dream and HTC Magic.  Next week it's the Palm Pre and then, just days later, Apple's Worldwide Developer Conference will bring anything from a new iPhone design to a touch tablet to a simple release of the iPhone 3.0 software for the current handset line.

 

Regardless of what happens with the hardware this month, there's one thing you need to understand about this battle - it's all about the software.

Phones have grown beyond the clamshell and the keyboard.  When the iPhone entered the realm it made the smartphone mainstream.  The Blackberry, the Treo and others had existed for years before the iPhone, but when Apple released their take on telephony, the game wasn't only changed, the playing field was altered as well.

Think about the iPod.  When it came out there was a great selection of mp3 players that looked nice, had great audio, were easy to use and could play your music on the go.  But then Apple paired iTunes with it's iPod.  It was not only a way to organize your music, it had a way to discover and buy new music built right into the architecture.  The iPod was sexy, sure, but that's not why it has won the music battle - iTunes is the reason.

And the same is happening in the phone world.  The iPhone is beautiful and elegant.  Is it the best?  Hell no, we haven't had a decent camera, video or cut and paste on this thing for 2 years yet it is responsible for 43% of the world's mobile web access traffic.  1 product, nearly 50% marketshare.  Why are we there?

It's the software, stupid.

My brother is a software engineer in Seattle and has had the G1 running Android since it was released.  On the eve of the Andriod arrival in Canada, I asked him for his thoughts.

 

The power of Android is in the open platform, and that holds a lot of promise.  People will be able to write apps that run anywhere -- on wide variety of phones, and also (eventually) in hundreds of places you never thought you'd want a widget.  The airplane seatbacks and car dashboards, for example, are perfect places to host Android.

But in this area Google is also losing to Apple.  The number of apps written for the iPhone is absolutely enormous.  Developers feel like there's real money to be made there and (just like in the Facebook apps days) there's a lot of hype around the potential of iPhone apps.  Even though you can do exactly the same things with an Android phone, there's none of the excitement around the platform and the app market is suffering as a result.

Android will continue to languish as a secondary platform for a few years, but this is also a huge strategic move for Google and they won't be abandoning it any time soon. I expect steady, ongoing improvements.  But iPhone has effectively captured the platform market in the same way that Windows did in the 90's.  And unlike Apple's MacOS during the same period, Android doesn't have any design cachet to keep it alive among technophiles and designers.

What Android really needs is a new, differentiating killer app.  Apple has better hardware with a better user experience.  Android needs something new and compelling so that it can bust out of the iPhone shadow.  But it would take something huge for that to happen and I'm not sure exactly what it would be (free handsets?).

Meanwhile, Blackberry and Palm definitely haven't ceded second place to Android and are also making their own iPhone killers.  This fragmentation of the secondary platform market is only going to make it harder for all of these also-rans to compete.


Normally the launch of an anticipated product like Android would cause at least a few geeks to camp out to get their paws on the piece, but with the Palm Pre and iPhone 3.0 coming in just a few days, you're best to just sit on the sidelines and wait until all the new arrivals have made their pitch.

 

catch the buzz ... pass it on.

 

 

Message Edited by Julez on 07-29-2009 04:13 PM
Message Edited by Laura on 08-21-2009 02:30 PM

Comments
by tachyondecay on ‎06-01-2009 08:24 AM

I've eagerly been awaiting June 2 and an Android phone.  As much as Apple likes to market itself as "cool", there's nothing cool about tethered appliances and maintaining draconian control over one's app store.  In that respect, Apple has been trending closer to its competitor, Microsoft, while promoting its superior product design to boost sales.  Clever but not admirable.

 

This isn't an anti-Apple rant though.  This is a pro-Android rant that will then segue into an anti-Canadian-teleco rant....

 

I find the idea of Google Android sexy (because I can program, although I'd have to learn Java first in this case), and its openness only makes it more so.  The ability to choose--and create--the apps that go on our phones really makes those phones ours, as opposed to just appliances we rent from the carrier.  They make the phones more like personal computers, which is great for me.

 

I currently have a non-smartphone from our local carrier, TBayTel. My contract's up, and I'm debating switching to pay-as-you-go, because I only use about three minutes a month. I don't call people, and few people call me. The phone has been off for more than two weeks now--I turned it off in a movie theatre and haven't bothered turning it back on yet.  Hence, smartphones really tempt me.  They'll let me do everything I want to do--check email, adjust my schedule, even surf the web--on the go, plus I can phone people.

 

But I'm not sure I'm ready to let Rogers gouge my wallet.  When I discussed the impending Android release with an American friend and complained about the cost of data plans, he asked, "But it's unlimited data, right?"  And I laughed.  Of course it's not unlimited data.  The state of data access plans in Canada is miserable.  The newer smartphones with built-in WiFi capability mitigate this problem, although if you're in a town with sparse WiFi coverage, then not by much.

 

In closing, it's not always about the software. While I'd love to get an Android phone, Rogers needs to sweeten the deal with better data plans.  If not, I'll just have to go without checking my email every five minutes.

 

Excuse me, I need to check my email....

© 2011 Future Shop. All rights reserved. For personal, noncommercial use.