Future Shop
Weekly Flyer My Account My Account My Account

Tech Blog

Is WiFI Frying Us?

by Blogger on 08-16-2010 08:05 AM - last edited on 04-22-2011 03:01 PM by Moderator

An interesting story is coming out of Ontario this week about a group of parents who are pulling their kids out of school because they say the school's open WiFi network is making their children sick.

 

Parents on the Simcoe County Safe School committee say kids in 14 local schools are showing varying problems they fear are caused by microwaves.

Rodney Palmer says the symptoms seem to disappear on weekends, and the parents know there's no evidence showing Wi-Fi is safe at the levels the kids are being exposed to.

He says no one has ever exposed children to microwave radiation for 13 years, starting at four years old, which he describes as an "experiment" that is underway in schools.

[source]

 

WiFi is ubiquitous. 

 

Drive down any street, sit in any cafe and open up your scanner and you'll be bombarded with channels you could join.  Office buildings, with many unique companies sharing floors and towers, blast out WiFi signals for their staff.  In our homes, we often have a local network blasting WiFi from our desktop so we can access the web on notebooks, iPads, iPods and phones.

 

So why is it that the kids are getting sick?


Susan Clarke, a former research consultant to the Harvard School of Public Health, says young children absorb much more radiation than older children and adults because of their thinner skulls.

Professor Magda Havas of Trent University in Peterborough, who does research on the health effects of electromagnetic radiation, says she is "increasingly concerned" about Wi-Fi use at schools.

[source]

 

I'd be curious to know your experiences with WiFi. 

 

Does it make you or your family sick, or is it a case of kids trying to pull a fast one?  As @andrewmacintyre responded "Mom, the wifi at school is making me sick so I have to stay home and play xbox, OK?"

 

catch the buzz ... pass it on.

 

 

Comments
by Moderator on 08-16-2010 08:08 AM

Question... Do they have WiFi at home?

by Exalted Expert / Community Ambassador on 08-16-2010 09:10 AM

I wondered about the dangers as well..... I ordered an EMF meter over the internet for a few hundred dollars.  I found most devices, you needed to be inches away to get a reading.  Of course, what are the dangers of low exposure over time, instead of high exposure for short duration.

 

Personally, other than cellphones and wifi enabled laptops.... my biggest problem are light dimmer switches..... they kick off the strongest reading while I'm sitting next to them while watching TV.

 

I love my LED clock in my bedroom as it doesn't make any ticking or motor noise.  But it kicks off an EMF reading.  How does power feed into your residential home.... is it next to the bedroom?  That may be a concern as well.

 

I wonder if Future Shop wants me walking through their store with my little meter....

 

Many schools to raise funds lease out their high rooftops to cellphone broadcasting.  Then again, perhaps school is the last place they should have cellphones because of the interruptions.

 

Some new church crosses may really be cellphone broadcasting antennas embedded inside the casing!  Have you visited the CN Tower?  I remember going many years ago and noticed my video camera would record so much "noise" because it was so close to the broadcasting antennas.

by Exalted Expert / Community Ambassador on 08-16-2010 09:41 AM

Even the simple refrigerator can kick off strong magnetic fields when operating....

 

I would also like to share this shocking story from Global TV's 16:9.

Click on this link http://www.globalnews.ca/programs/16x9/video.html and scroll to Episode 183.  Check out the videos titled "Shedding Some Light".

 

I'm not a big fan of CF lighting because the bulbs are so fragile and wear quickly when the lights are turned on and off frequently.... I like LED lighting, but the light is harsher (use a diffuser) and dim.  That will get better in the coming years.

by tachyondecay on 08-16-2010 11:55 AM

I don't know, is it?  We have a track record of cheerfully using a resource only to find, later down the road, it was a bad idea.  Lead, CFCs, the '80s. . . .  I happen to like Wi-Fi, and I really hope it isn't frying my brain, because then I'd have to stop using it.  But it would be silly of me to say, "No, Wi-Fi is harmless," because I don't know what's going on.

 

From the general acceptance of Wi-Fi by society, however, it seems like the majority of scientists agree that Wi-Fi poses little in the ways of health risks.  The majority have been wrong before, and this may be one of those cases.  Until they reverse their position, however, I am not going to turn off my wireless router.  As pointed out, Wi-Fi is ubiquitous.  My wireless network is a drop in the ocean.  It's possible that twenty years from now we'll all be shaking our heads at how stupid and naive we were back in 2010: Wi-Fi, a good idea? What were we thinking?  At the moment, however, cases like this one, where many children are getting sick, do not seem widespread (are they?).  If Wi-Fi is the culprit, it is awfully selective.

 

The CBC news article on this incident mentions at the end Lakehead University, which is notable for eschewing Wi-Fi on campus.  I happen to attend Lakehead University.  Possible health risks aside, on a practical level I have anecdotal reservations against a "wired" model.  Many of the ethernet ports don't work, or if they do work are inconveniently situated, and they are really only ubiquitous in our one "ATAC" (Advanced Technology and Academic Centre) building.  Maybe this is just the poor implementation of a single administration, but Wi-Fi in general is a more convenient solution to an Internet-enabled campus.

by Blogger on 08-16-2010 01:43 PM

There was an article a while back about a New Zealand community that was complaining about the ills of microwave radiation. Everyone in town was getting sick, with headaches and nausea.

 

During the first hearing regarding the tower they were all embarrassed to find that it hadn't been turned on yet. Put frankly: anyone claiming that Wi-Fi is making them sick is simply full of it.

by JakeD(anon) on 09-13-2010 08:57 AM

This is fear-mongering.  Radiation in both the 2.4 and 5 GHz bands is non-ionizing, which means it does not break the cellular bond.  It is not harmful.  5 GHz especially so, while 2.4 GHz (what all Microwave ovens run at) has the potentially unpleasant side effect of inducing heat in water molecules.  Neither can make you sick. Re. the Simcoe county safe school - perfect example of mass hysteria (or bad air, or bad water).  Of course, first choice of scapegoat is the one least understood.